When schools decide to impose a school uniform on their students, they usually do it after careful consideration, weighing the pros and cons of such a drastic decision.
Learn more about the pros and cons of uniform policies in public schools. The prevalence of uniforms in public schools continues to rise in the United States, as parents and school administrators exert efforts to keep our schools safe environments.
Even with these compelling statistics, however, there are other statistics that argue that uniforms are not as beneficial as school administrators and parents are encouraged to believe. Opponents cite research that shows a lack of individualism and comfort among students, working to actually decrease student learning and success.
Thus, the question still remains: The Benefits of Public School Uniforms: Safer Learning Environment Many school administrators and parents believe that uniforms create a better learning environment at school.
First and foremost, many administrators claim that students are not as distracted by how they look, and therefore, spend more time learning at school. This allows students to focus more on their schoolwork, rather than social appearances. In addition, with the visual uniformity present across all students, the instance of school pride has increased.
Similar to athletic team uniforms, proponents argue that dressing cohesively increases pride, unity, and a renewed commitment to the school. With uniforms, a more professional tone is set in school, encouraging students to take their studies more seriously.
Uniforms at school also reduce the prevalence of violence, which is a major concern for many public schools. Outsiders who do not belong on campus are easily identified, and thus, do not pose a great threat to the students.
A school may only allow green or yellow polo shirts and khaki bottoms, for example, preventing students from wearing the traditional gang identifying colors of red and blue. Accessories such as bandanas, another distinguishing gang clothing characteristic, can also be eliminated from the school dress code.
When it is more difficult to identify members of gangs in school, the fights and violence between rival gangs decrease.
By denying students the opportunity to fully express their unique personality through the clothing they select, individualism is unable to develop to its fullest capacity.
When children select their own clothing, they are able to develop confidence and independence, characteristics vital to personality development and adult success. Controlling the socialization process could harm the student as an adult, as they are not prepared for the real world, where they will indeed by judged by their appearances.
Proponents of uniforms argue that they will bring conformity among students, resulting in increased safety, but when students are limited through what they may wear, they will find other ways to react against authority and the limits uniform policies place on their individual nature.
Without the outlet of expression in their clothes, students may turn to other avenues of self-expression that may be viewed as even more inappropriate than clothing, such as nontraditional hairstyles or make-up or more importantly, acting out against school and parental authority through the decisions they make and behaviors they exhibit.
In addition, opponents argue that uniforms may not be comfortable for all students, which will limit learning as students worry about their appearance. Student comfort is important in order to maximize learning outcomes, and uniforms may stymie academic focus.
For example, the uniform standard may require students to wear polo shirts that are tucked into khaki slacks. Students who are overweight may feel very self-conscious about their bodies.
Additionally, female students may feel insecure about their bodies and feel that having a tucked in shirt will bring attention to their developing figures.
When students do not feel comfortable in the required school uniform, their focus will shift from learning. Children, especially those in middle and high school, are constantly concerned about their appearance, and wearing a school uniform will not alleviate this concern.
Addressing the Issue of Decreased Violence among Gangs An additional argument put forth by those in favor of uniforms advocates that they decrease violence among students involved in gangs because there will be less chance of identifying gangs members through the clothing colors they wear.
Though students may be limited in wearing a particular color, they will find other ways to identify their participation in gangs, from the hairstyles they select to how they wear the required uniform.
For example, students in gangs may all choose the same type of belt to show their unity or shave their hair in the same fashion. The Mixed Response from Parents: Cost-effectiveness of Wearing Uniforms Whereas some parents believe that uniforms are more cost-effective than purchasing the latest stylish clothes, other parents argue that the cost of uniforms is steep.
Typically, uniforms are more expensive up-front, as the parent must invest in all of the staples at the beginning of the school year, for example, there are collared or polo shirts of various colors, khaki or black pants, black or brown belts and shoes, and solid colored sweaters.
Though this is an expense at the beginning, there are only small expenses that need to be made as the school year progresses.Discipline cannot be simply put on the issue of school uniforms as it is up to not only the teachers but the parents of the students who truly encourage discipline.
Report Post Like Reply. Dress Codes and Uniforms. National Association of Elementary School Principals, official OERI position or policy Concerns about school safety have also prompted interest in strict dress of Education’s Mantlal on School Uniforms notes, “Uniforms by themselves cannot solve all of the problems of school discipline, but they can be one.
The board of directors in any school entity may impose limitations on dress and may require pupils to wear standard dress or uniforms. Dress policies may be applicable throughout the school entity or may be applicable to one or more school buildings within the school entity.
While I believe school uniforms may help slightly i do not believe they fully encourage discipline as mush broader background is needed in order to encourage discipline. Discipline cannot be simply put on the issue of school uniforms as it is up to not only the teachers but the parents of the students who truly encourage discipline.
Abstract. Approximately half of the public schools in the United States require uniforms or a formal dress policy and many are intended to reduce discipline problems and improve school climate.
It is also important to consider the school's total discipline data and school police data after having implemented the school uniform policy. Compared to the year prior to the uniform policy being implemented, the total discipline referrals at this middle school were reduced by (%).